Skip to main content icon/video/no-internet

Manipulation Check

Experiments are conducted in communication research in order to determine if manipulating one variable will have an effect on another variable. The variable that is manipulated is called the independent variable. A dependent variable changes based on the manipulation of the independent variable. For example, if a researcher were interested in the effect of violent video games on aggression among young adults, he or she could manipulate the type of violent video game along with the amount of time the participant spent playing these games each week and then measure participant levels of aggression after playing violent video games. In this example, the violent video games would be the independent variable and aggression would be the dependent variable because video game exposure is being manipulated and the level of aggression depends on the amount of exposure to violent video games. One problem the researcher might run into is that participants may not feel that the video games are particularly violent, which is a potential threat to internal validity. Internal validity pertains to the ability of the researcher to conclude that the findings from the study are accurate. In order to overcome this problem, researchers incorporate manipulation checks into their research design. Manipulation checks are a way to help ensure that the independent variable has effectively been manipulated or that the participants understood the independent variable in the way that the researcher planned. This entry discusses the use of manipulation in experimental research. It also explains how to conduct manipulation checks and why it is important to do so.

Manipulation in Experimental Research

The goal of experimental research is to control variables as much as possible to draw conclusions about the cause-and-effect relationship between two or more variables. Researchers use manipulation in their research design to determine if changes in one variable impact another variable or variables. Three of the more common types of manipulations researchers might do include instructional, environmental, and confederate/stooge.

Types of Manipulation

Instructional Manipulation

For instructional manipulations, the researcher alters the written or oral instructions across different groups of participants. The participants in the control group would be given one set of instructions while the participants in the control group would receive a different set of instructions. For example, if a researcher wanted to manipulate confidentiality, he or she may frequently mention confidentiality procedures in one set of instructions while leaving out any mention of confidentiality in the second set of instructions. After data collection was completed, the researcher would compare and contrast differences between the control group and the treatment group based on their exposure to the manipulated instructions.

Environmental Manipulation

Some experiments occur in highly controlled research laboratories. Others may occur in other contexts (e.g., classrooms). In either case, the researcher may decide to manipulate the environment. For example, the researcher may have a fire alarm go off partway through the experiment. A researcher also might manipulate the temperature of the laboratory. Another example of environmental manipulations occurred in the famous illumination studies conducted by Elton Mayo and colleagues. For this study, researchers altered the illumination of the lights in a factory to see what the optimal level of light would enhance worker efficiency.

...

  • Loading...
locked icon

Sign in to access this content

Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL

  • Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
  • Read modern, diverse business cases
  • Explore hundreds of books and reference titles

Sage Recommends

We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.

Loading