Entry
Reader's guide
Entries A-Z
Subject index
Heteroglossia
Heteroglossia means different ‘speech-ness' or differentiated speech. A given language is not unitary but stratified; heteroglossia is a mix of languages and world views. The idea of heteroglossia is associated with the Russian theorist Mikhail Bakhtin (1895–1975), who saw everyday speech as a conglomerate of ‘sublanguages', always used from a particular perspective and context and directed towards another. This draws attention to how we hear and speak.
Heteroglossia describes the stratification of language into different genres, dialects, generations or sociolects based on age group, gender, socio-grouping, discipline or profession and so on. There are languages that are tendentious and those that represent the voices of authorities, various circles and particular fashions. These different languages are appropriated in everyday speech.
Each stratification as a language within languages is historical, contextual and continually evolving. People do not remain within a given genre or other stratification. Rather, they are continually borrowing from different stratifications, each influencing the other. A group of professionals from a given discipline with their own particular jargon, for example, lawyers, engineers or doctors, will have their own technical language stratification. However, this is used in the context of everyday speech, which is made up of multiple stratifications. A particular professional or technical language mingles with everyday speech-ness so that it is not spoken as a separate entity but, rather, coalesces with other languages. Thus, professional jargon is itself influenced by values and norms across everyday languages.
These languages are socially unequal and therefore hierarchical. Each language has its own strategic intent, values and meaning. In heteroglossia, words or utterances are never neutral; their meanings are always context driven. Context in this sense refers not just to the speaker and the words used but also extends to the wider, more diffuse environment, for example, day of the week or time of day. Context in this wide sense colours the intended and created meanings of words.
Language is also ideological in the sense of advancing ideas. Every utterance reflects a separating out of a value from the past and is directed towards the future. Every utterance responds to that which was uttered previously and is coloured by the anticipated response. A response to an utterance comes from a myriad of possible responses reflecting particular values, weighting and an invitation to answer in that given moment. Everyday speech is thus imbued with the speech of others as we interact with one another.
Heteroglossia and Monologism
It is conflict and inequity that distinguish the idea of heteroglossia from that of polyphony. Polyphony refers to multiple voices without reference to the nature of their interrelationship. In contrast, in heteroglossia, national languages and their subsets are imbued with historical and social conflict. Thus, from a Bakhtinian lens, language stratifications embody the conflict among social forces that results in particular representations and authoritative discourses. Everyday speech reflects conflicting social forces.
Bakhtinian scholars highlight the ethical undertones of his work; Bakhtin viewed heteroglossia as ethically superior to the notion of a singular authoritative language (monologic). Language that is stratified may become monologized by the emergence and dominance of a single authoritative voice.
...
- Alinsky, Saul
- Argyris, Chris
- Bateson, Gregory
- Boal, Augusto
- Chataway, Cynthia Joy
- Dewey, John
- Emery, Fred
- Fals Borda, Orlando
- Freire, Paulo
- Gadamer, Hans-Georg
- Horton, Myles
- Kincheloe, Joe
- Lewin, Kurt
- marino, dian
- Martín-Baró, Ignacio
- Nielsen, Kurt Aagaard
- Noffke, Susan
- Schön, Donald
- Toulmin, Stephen
- Whyte, William Foote
- Wittgenstein, Ludwig
- Academic Discourse
- Agency
- Appreciative Intelligence
- Authenticity
- Bakhtinian Dialogism
- Bildung
- Community of Inquiry
- Communities of Practice
- Conscientization
- Critical Friend
- Critical Reference Group
- Dialogue
- Double-Loop Learning
- Empowerment
- Engaged Scholarship
- Hegemony
- Heteroglossia
- Heutagogy
- Identity
- Knowledge Democracy
- Metaphor
- Non-Indigenous Ally
- Organizational Culture
- Positionality
- Subalternity
- Sustainability
- Systems Thinking
- Tacit Knowledge
- Taylorism
- Technical Action Research
- Tempered Radical
- Transformative Learning
- Vivencia
- Voice
- Epistemology
- Experiential Knowing
- Experiential Learning
- Extended Epistemology
- Hawaiian Epistemology
- Māori Epistemology
- Practical Knowing
- Ubuntu
- Covenantal Ethics
- Ethics and Moral Decision-Making
- Feminist Ethics
- Indigenous Research Ethics and Practice
- Institutional Review Board
- Capacity Building
- Citizen Participation
- Co-Generative Learning
- Environmental Justice
- Knowledge Mobilization
- Local Self-Governance
- Social Accountability
- Social Justice
- Women's Political Empowerment
- Action Evaluation
- Advocacy and Inquiry
- Autobiography
- Bricolage Process
- Case Study
- Citizen Report Card
- Citizens' Juries
- Cognitive Mapping
- Collaborative Data Analysis
- Community Dialogue
- Community Mapping
- Computer-Based Instruction
- Concept Mapping
- Conflict Management
- Convergent Interviewing
- Critical Reflection
- Democratic Dialogue
- Descriptive Review
- Development Coalitions
- Dialogue Conferences
- Digital Storytelling
- Discourse Analysis
- Fishbone Diagram
- Focus Groups
- Interviews
- Journaling
- Listening Guide
- Microplanning
- Multi-Stakeholder Dialogue
- Narrative Inquiry
- Organizational Storytelling
- Participatory Monitoring
- Photovoice
- Research Circles
- Search Conference
- Social Audit
- Stakeholder Analysis
- Storytelling
- World Café, The
- Action Learning
- Action Science
- Anti-Oppression Research
- Appreciative Inquiry and Research Methodology
- Appreciative Inquiry and Sustainable Value Creation
- Arts-Based Action Research
- Asset-Based Community Development
- Citizen Science
- Classroom-Based Action Research
- Clinical Inquiry
- Collaborative Action Research
- Collaborative Developmental Action Inquiry
- Collaborative Management Research
- Community-Based Participatory Research
- Community-Based Research
- Comprehensive District Planning
- Co-Operative Inquiry
- Critical Action Learning
- Critical Participatory Action Research
- Critical Utopian Action Research
- Dialogic Inquiry
- Ethnography
- Evaluative Inquiry
- Feminist Participatory Action Research
- First Person Action Research
- Grounded Theory
- Indigenist Research
- Indigenous Research Methods
- Interactive Research
- Intervention Research in Management
- Large-Group Action Research
- Learning History
- Living Life as Inquiry
- Narrative
- Oral History
- Participatory Action Research
- Participatory Design Programming
- Participatory Governance
- Participatory Learning and Action
- Participatory Rapid Appraisal
- Participatory Rural Appraisal
- Participatory Theatre
- Participatory Urban Planning
- Performed Ethnography
- Practice Development
- Practitioner Inquiry
- Pragmatic Action Research
- Process Consultation
- Qualimetrics Intervention Research
- Quantitative Methods
- Reflective Practice
- Second Person Action Research
- Soft Systems Methodology
- Strategic Planning
- Strengths-Based Approach
- Systemic Action Research
- Systems Psychodynamics
- Theatre of the Oppressed
- Third Person Action Research
- Transpersonal Inquiry
- Work-Based Learning
- Youth Participatory Action Research
- Cycles of Action and Reflection
- Data Analysis
- Disseminating Action Research
- Gender Issues
- Generalizability
- Information and Communications Technology and Organizational Change
- Integrating Grounded Theory
- Intersubjectivity
- Meta-Methodology
- Mode 1 and Mode 2 Knowledge Production
- Quality
- Reliability
- Rigour
- Transferability
- Validity
- Antigonish Movement
- Centre for Action Research in Professional Practice
- Collaborative Action Research Network
- Community Design Centres
- Community-University Partnership Programme
- Community-Campus Partnerships for Health
- Community-University Research Partnerships
- Cornell Participatory Action Research Network
- Dig Where You Stand Movement
- Disabled People's Organizations
- Global Alliance for Community-Engaged Research
- Gonogobeshona
- Grameen Bank
- Highlander Research and Education Center
- Institute of Development Studies
- International Council for Adult Education
- International Participatory Research Network
- Jipemoyo Project
- LGBT
- Maya Women of Chajul
- Mondragón Co-Operatives
- Norwegian Industrial Democracy Movement
- Office of Community-Based Research
- Research Initiatives, Bangladesh
- Social Movement Learning Movement
- Society for Participatory Research in Asia
- Tavistock Institute
- Work Research Institute, The
- World Congresses of Action Research
- Action Turn, The
- Aesthetics
- Communitarianism
- Critical Constructivism
- Critical Pedagogy
- Critical Race Theory
- Critical Realism
- Frankfurt School
- Hermeneutics
- Ontology
- Phenomenology
- Philosophy of Science
- Phrónêsis
- Positive Organizational Scholarship and Appreciative Inquiry
- Praxeology
- Praxis
- Téchnê
- Action Anthropology
- Adult Education
- Agriculture and Ecological Integrity
- Community Development
- Criminal Justice Systems
- Design Research
- Development Action Research
- Educational Action Research
- Environment and Climate Change
- Evaluation
- Health Care
- Health Education
- Health Promotion
- Higher Education
- HIV Prevention and Support
- Human Rights
- Information Systems
- Insider Action Research
- Inter-Organizational Action Research
- Labour-Managed Firms
- New Product Development
- Nursing
- Operations Management
- Organization Development
- Participatory Disaster Management
- Project Management
- Regional Development
- Subaltern Studies
- Voluntary Sector
- Workers' Participation in Occupational Health and Safety
- Work-Family Interventions
- Dissertation Writing
- Facilitation
- Supervising Action Research Theses and Dissertations
- Teaching Action Researchers
- Christian Spirituality of Action
- Confucian Principles
- Islamic Practice
- Jewish Belief, Thought and Practice
- Karma Theory
- Liberation Theology
- Mindful Inquiry
- Theological Action Research
- Activity Theory
- Complexity Theory
- Constructivism
- Feminism
- Field Theory
- Humanism
- Liberation Psychology
- Living Theories
- Marxism
- Post-Colonial Theory
- Postmodernism
- Pragmatism
- Relational-Cultural Theory
- Social Constructionism
- Social Learning
- Socio-Technical Systems
- Symbolic Interactionism
- Theories of Action
- Asset Mapping
- Force Field Analysis
- Geographic Information Systems
- Ladder of Inference
- Ladder of Participation
- Learning Pathways Grid
- Loading...
Get a 30 day FREE TRIAL
-
Watch videos from a variety of sources bringing classroom topics to life
-
Read modern, diverse business cases
-
Explore hundreds of books and reference titles
Sage Recommends
We found other relevant content for you on other Sage platforms.
Have you created a personal profile? Login or create a profile so that you can save clips, playlists and searches